blessedmakerCurator
Overall6.5Fear3Atmos.6.5Gore6
It's hard to imagine that an Alien movie (my favorite franchise) and a highly respected director who made another one of my favorites, Se7en, could combine to create something disappointing. Two legends meet and the outcome is flat. Some quick research explains it - a contentious, chaotic production in which David Fincher was handcuffed in his creative freedom, and daily rewrites to the script that would show up on the day of shooting. All a recipe for disaster that even the talented Fincher could not overcome.
Even saying that, you can see glimpses of Fincher's deft direction. It's a moody film, much like Alien, and it also shifts back to one Alien vs a mostly unarmed group. But where Alien terrified with the mystery of the unknown in the dark corners of an indifferent cosmos, which harbors a terrifying existence, Fincher creates nihilistic darkness. That feeling lands but it didn't make me like the film more, nor did it scare. It did depress. It's my least favorite of the original four, but it can be argued it is not the worst directed.
Pros
• Good direction. David Fincher is truly good at what he does, and despite the worst of situations, the art is still recognizable - it's not a bad film and there are beautiful shots throughout.
• The close-ups of the Alien are good, the practical shines in these moments.
• Charles Dance as Clemens is wonderful, a convincing role opposite Ripley, and the relationship felt natural and developed at a good pace.
Cons
• Characters (other than Clemens, and Ripley obviously) that I downright do not care about. The first two films had memorable characters that were easy to root for and that I hated to see die.
• Killing Hicks and Newt still feels wrong (see the point above), would have been nice to have more characters to care about.
• Rod puppetry looks bad. Aged like milk. Juxtaposed against the close-up body suit of the Alien, it highlights the technical limitations even more.
• Couldn't care less about the religious undertones and the idea of the prisoners finding God or a purpose beyond their life sentence.
• The film lacked the scares and suspense of the first two.