watchdarkly
Back to Alien: Resurrection

Reviews

Alien: Resurrection(1997)

Curator reviews are written by the curator after watching the film.

1 review

Sort
blessedmakerCurator
Overall7.1Fear3Atmos.7Gore8
Note - this review covers the theatrical release, the version the director signed off on. As with the rest of the quadrilogy, the theatrical cut is the one I grade. Resurrection is my third favorite Alien film among the original four (Alien, Aliens, this, Alien 3). All of the Alien films are technically well made in my opinion, mostly as far as direction is concerned, but it's the last two of the originals that deviate from greatness because of reasons not unknown. As I was watching Resurrection I tried to put my finger on what felt "off" about the movie. The intro plays a dark, somber and disconcerting soundtrack with credits rolling over disturbing twisted images of body horror - you can see human and alien imagery with mutations of one and/or the other. The stage is set, like okay this is going to be a serious dark adventure (like the previous ones). Then you get the introduction of the crew of the Betty, a rough around the edges mercenary crew - the type of folks that if you walk into the wrong bar you'd get your ass whooped, and your spouse or partner would get unwanted sexual remarks and looks, maybe even some aggressive touching. They're gross, and unfiltered. One of them makes monkey noises and drops a knife into a paraplegic's leg because, well, why not, he can't feel it right? The captain objectifies the younger, new crew member - "she is severely fuckable". In a serious Alien film we get serious tonal whiplash via misogynistic and "dirty old pervert" dialogue and characters. [SPOILERS] I'll give you a specific example. The Ripley clone lab scene, one of the darkest and bleakest scenes in the entire franchise in my opinion. Director Jeunet flexes his body horror muscles; the failed cloning attempts are grotesque, showing off a twisted combination of human and alien DNA in giant brine jars, it really makes your skin crawl and succeeds in its mission to make you feel sad, and horrified. Ripley herself wears the emotion on her face when encountering each failed experiment until finally she reaches a live conscious clone, in pain, with sad punishing alien and human deformities. It begs to be killed. Ripley sets the place on fire, and what do we get at the last shot? We get Johner with the quip: "What's the big deal, man? Fuckin' waste of ammo. Must be a chick thing." And that's what I mean by tonal whiplash and that's where the "offness" comes from. The writer and director have each said since that they wanted different films. The script is tongue-in-cheek, sarcastic space cowboys dealing with Aliens, and it undercuts its own darkest scene with a joke. The direction is dark, moody body horror fantasy that plays those jokes loud. The two are at odds with one another, and it shows. With that out of the way, I enjoyed watching this film much more than Alien 3. The film is fun, fast paced, and the creature design and action is good, for the most part. I say most part because some of the CGI hasn't aged well, but it's mostly practical, and the practical is quite good especially with respect to the Newborn. There's plenty of body horror here, and a lot of it very well done. Once you understand the different philosophical approaches to the material at play, I think it makes for a more enjoyable watch. Pros • Body horror is effective and engineered artistically well • Good practical effects make for enjoyable monster set pieces and action • Haunting soundtrack • Fast paced which works well for this story Cons • Inconsistent tone, different ideas and philosophy regarding the material results in a final product that doesn't have an identity • A lot of the Betty crew are unlikable - the misogyny is irritating and eye-rollingly bad. • CGI hasn't aged well